Trying to find some amazing “would you rather” or “this or that” visual templates you can post on your Instagram (or your Snapchat) story? We’ve compiled a list of 25 absolutely perfect and amazing would you rather templates for Instagram.
Of course, everybody loves using Instagram and spends a lot of time viewing their feed and stories, so why not spice up your own story with one of these “this or that” templates?
Sometimes they’re pretty straightforward, but some of these visual templates can get really freaky and interesting – they’ll definitely make you think twice before you pick the correct choice for you.
What to do when you see a Would You Rather story on Instagram
If you’ve ever seen one of these in your stories feed before (and given their popularity, chances are that you have already), you’ll probably know how to play the Would You Rather game.
Basically, take a screenshot of the story with the visual template, and use Instagram’s built-in photo editor to circle all your choices.
There’s really no need to use another (more complicated) photo editor, as the embedded Instagram will do the job perfectly.
When you’re done circling all your answers, either post it to your own story tagging your friend, or send the screenshot in their DM’s.
Instead of screenshotting the template, you can also save it by holding the story for about three seconds on your device and pressing “save to gallery”.
Here is our full list of 25+ amazing “Would You Rather” and “This or That” Instagram story templates:
We’ve collected this list based on creations that were made by the Instagram community. You can always find the original creator of the template in the username Instagram handle in the templates.
If you’re visiting this page on a phone, hold the image for three seconds and press “save to gallery” to use it on your own Instagram story. They’re already in the perfect size, we’ve made it pretty easy for you!
You can check out the source of every template in the image itself. Be sure to check their Instagram accounts or click the image for a link!
1) The musical edition
What would you respond when there’s music involved? Would you go for something as timeless and classic as Vinyl, or are you a streaming fan?
2) For the Harry Potter fans
Whether you’ve read the books, seen the movies, or perhaps even both – this Harry Potter-inspired Would You Rather template is just for you.
3) Hot or cold
Would you rather be too cold or too hot? It’s just one of the many this or that questions in this very fun template you can use. There’s even a question about superpowers!
4) Another WYR about general life
This one is pretty comparable to the previous one and just fun to fill in. Time travelers, would you rather go back into the past or take a glimpse at what the future may look like?
5) Flying or superfast running? Tough choice!
Sometimes you’ll just have to think things through before you pick one of the answers, and this template can definitely be a tricky one.
6) Take your pick
We must admit, it’s pretty difficult to outweigh visiting every single country in the world against actually going to space. Curious to see what your friends think? Definitely use this Instagram story template below.
7) Concerts, baby!
Want to see your favorite artists perform on stage? Let’s see which ones you prefer and would rather see in a live performance.
8) Too many carbs, but super tasty
Okay, okay – some of these options below probably aren’t ideal for your health, but they sure are tasty. Lasagna or mac & cheese? Such a difficult decision!
9) Dr. Doolittle or the ultimate polyglot?
Speaking to animals may be incredibly useful, but on the other hand, speaking every language in the world is pretty amazing too.
10) Another random questionnaire
Telepathy or telekinesis? These superhero questions are always the toughest.
11) Get to know me
If you think about it, these This or That and Would You Rather story templates are the perfect way to get to know one another better. So what are you waiting for, download one of these images and get to posting!
12) No internet? Nightmare!
This would you rather question would probably scare pretty much everyone out there to death – having to choose between not having your phone or not having internet must be tough.
13) The impossible edition
If you thought that some of these questions were tough, wait until you see this one! The creator collected a bunch of super difficult this or that questions, as you can see in the template below.
14) Simple, yet fun
Sometimes the most simple would you rather story templates are also the most fun – you won’t find a lot of questions on here, but I’d be pretty interested to see what my friends would choose.
15) That first question is just nasty
If you’re scared of bugs, we’re pretty sure that you won’t like this template. Just take a look at the first question, as it is enough to turn your stomach around.
16) The Style Edition
Where are all the fashionistas out there? This Would You Rather story template is absolutely perfect for you. Would you rather have bags or shoes in your life? Heels or flats? Touch choices all around.
17) The Christmas spirit
What better way to get into the Christmas mood by posting this amazing Christmas Edition Would You Rather? on your Instagram story. Perhaps we can finally put the real tree vs. fake tree discussion to rest now.
18) Junk food
This isn’t only a “would you rather”, but a “would you rather eat”, and we’re going into the less healthy junk food section. Gummy bears or gummy worms? Pick your side!
19) iPhone vs Android
Are you an iPhone or an Android type of person? How about Spotify and Apple Music?
20) Another fun this or that template
Socks or slippers, dogs or cats, flats or heels, autumn or spring? This is a general Would You Rather template you can use on your story.
21) Take your pick
Sometimes the layout or style can really make things pop more, and this simple and clear template is really aesthetic to use.
22) Not all of them have to be circled
Okay, sometimes you don’t need to circle around your answers, but you can just check them instead. Rain or sunshine? Put a cross with whatever you’re vibing with.
23) A fun this or that
They always say that choosing is losing, right? Here’s another fun This or That template for a story in between your regular stories.
24) Another food edition
Food is definitely one of the most important things in the world, and people clearly have wildly varying tastes in food. What’s yours?
25) What would you rather be?
Would you rather be happy and content but not achieve much, or never be satisfied but achieve a lot? A pretty deep question right from the get-go, which is why this can also be one of the more interesting templates.
Further reading
If you’ve enjoyed this list of “Would your rather” and “This or That” Instagram story templates, perhaps you’ll also enjoy our list of 250+ fairy comments you can post on Instagram and TikTok. Looking for a spicy version? We’ve also compiled a list of 100+ flirty fair comment oneliners that will definitely make you stand out. Or perhaps you’d like another Instagram story game? Be sure to check out an astrology bingo game based on your zodiac sign too.
